There's something else too. Mytho thinks that since we stopped the Innocent from being eaten the Shepherd wanted to make things fair by giving up our identity to the wolves. He said something that'd point to Mytho if they paid attention. About how the protector was like in a storybook.

We think if they know who everybody is on their side that means tonight they'll get the Thief to steal our powers and eat either you or us, maybe even try for the Innocent again.